NO REMEDY FOR MISTAKEN IDENTITY ARREST

Joseph Thomas was pulled over by an officer for a traffic violation. The officer then properly checked to see if Thomas had any warrants. The officer found no warrants in the name of Joseph Thomas but he did find a warrant in the name of Joshua Thomas for having six outstanding parking tickets. For some unknown reason Joshua Thomas’ warrant had Joseph Thomas’ drivers license number on it, although it had different addresses.

Thomas sued in Federal court on various state and Federal grounds, including violation of his Fourth Amendment and Due Process rights. He argued that under Illinois law officers had no right to prosecute individuals for failure to pay parking tickets.

The Seventh Circuit ruled that Thomas did not have standing to sue under the grounds that there was no right to arrest someone for failure to pay parking tickets since it was Joshua Tomas, not Joseph Thomas who failed to pay his parking tickets.

Thomas’ Due Process claim was that he did not receive notice that he could be arrested for not paying traffic tickets. But the Court easily denied this claim since Joseph Thomas did not have any outstanding parking tickets he would not have received notice even if the city gave such notices.

As to the Fourth Amendment claim the court citing Supreme Court decision in Atwater found that if there is probable cause for the arrest there is no Fourth Amendment violation even if there is no right to arrest the defendant under the statute.

But the problem here is that Thomas suffered a grievous wrong. He was arrested and forced to put up bail for a crime he did not commit. But there appears to be no remedy for the wrong. Usually in these cases you argue the lack of probable cause. But that’s a tough standard to meet. Without really discussing it the Seventh Circuit seems to accept that the officer had probable cause to arrest Thomas based on the fact that the warrant for Joshua Thomas had Joseph Thomas’ license number on it.