NINTH CIRCUIT GRANTS FOIA REQUEST FOR CONFIDENTIAL INFORMANT INFORMATION

Gordon Skinner testified for the government at Wiliam Pickard’s narcotics trial. He admitted being an informant for the DEA and to providing information about Pickard. DEA agents also testified that Skinner was an informant.

After Pickard was convicted he made a Freedom of Information (FOI) request to the DEA for information about Skinner and his relation to the agency. The request was rejected and he appealed, first administratively and then to the District Court. After the DEA’s first motion for summary judgement was denied it made a Glomar motion in which it neither denied or admitted that Skinner was an informant. After the motion was granted Pickard appealed to the Ninth Circuit.

The Ninth Circuit reversed the District Court’s ruling and ordered the DEA to provide an index of documents that would comply with Pickard’s request along with any objections it has to providing individual documents.

The release of FOI documents is governed by the Freedom of Information Act. 5 U.S.C. § 552(c)(2) forbids the release of information about an informant unless the agency has officially confirmed the person as a confidential informant. The DEA argued that since there was no official confirmation it did not have to release the documents. However the Court ruled that since Skinner had admitted his status on the witness stand and since the U. S. attorney had called Skinner as a witness and asked him about his activities as an informant, it was not necessary for there to be an official statement on behalf of the agency affirming his status.